What to Learn from this Article?
What to Learn from this Article?
Rare presentation of isolated Trapezium fracture: diagnosis and management.
Case Report | Volume 5 | Issue 3 | JOCR July-Sep 2015 | Page 29-31 | Ranajit Panigrahi, Manas Ranjan Biswal, Nishit Palo, Naresh Panigrahi. DOI: 10.13107/jocr.2250-0685.300.
Authors: Ranajit Panigrahi, Manas Ranjan Biswal, Nishit Palo, Naresh Panigrahi
Department of Orthopaedics, Hi-Tech Medical College &Hospital, Bhubaneswar.
Address of Correspondence
Dr Ranajit Panigrahi,
Department of Orthopaedics, Hi-Tech Medical College & Hospital, Pandra, Rasulgarh, Bhubaneswar, Odisha.
E mail – firstname.lastname@example.org
Introduction: Isolated trapezium fractures accounts for 3-5% of all carpal fractures, are often missed on initial presentation. Trapezial fractures should be treated early given its importance in grip and pinch. We report a rare isolated coronal fracture of trapezium, following fall on an outstretched hand.
Case Report: A 40-year-old right lady presented with pain in right hand due to fall on out stretched hand. The radial half of wrist and lower forearm were swollen. Tenderness over trapezium and 1st metacarpal base with terminal thumb movements restricted. X-Ray revealed undisplaced incomplete coronal fracture of the trapezium. CT scan confirmed coronal split fracture of the trapezium with a major volar fragment and a dorsal fragment without articular involvement. The patient refused operative intervention. Fracture was treated conservatively. The follow-up radiographs showed normal articular relationship of the trapezium with the base of first metacarpal and scaphoid. The fracture healed with no complications.
Conclusion: Carpal fracture diagnosis requires high clinical suspicion. X-Rays and CT scans define pattern orientation and understanding.
Keywords: Trapezium, Trauma, Fractures, Coronal, X-Ray, CT.
Isolated coronal fracture of the trapezium is rare and accounts for only 3-5% of all carpal fractures . Vertical sagittal split fractures of the body of trapezium occur rarely in isolation and accounts for 20% of these fractures. . Trapezium Fracture is not commonly seen after fall on an outstretched hand. These fractures often go unrecognized and are missed on initial presentation. These are important fractures to detect and treat early given the importance of the trapezium in the carpometacarpal joint in actions such as grip and pinch but a universal protocol for its treatment is lacking. We report a rare isolated coronal fracture of trapezium, following fall on outstretched hand.
A 40-year-old right hand dominant female patient presented to the Out Patient Department with pain in the right hand due to a fall on the out stretched hand. Swelling present on radial half of the wrist and lower forearm (Fig 1 & 2). She had pain over the radial side of the wrist, tenderness over the trapezium and base of first metacarpal with no tenderness in the anatomical snuff box with no crepitus or abnormal bony movements. Movements of her thumb was only restricted in the terminal range, palmar flexion and radial deviation were painful and her neuro-vascular status was intact.
Investigations: A plain radiograph of the left hand revealed a incomplete fracture trapezium similar to Walker Type-1 but is incomplete with intact 1st CMC Joint (Fig 3 & 4). CT scan confirmed the coronal split fracture of the trapezium with a major volar fragment and a dorsal fragment without articular involvement (Fig 5)
Treatment: The patient refused operative intervention. A Cock up back slab was given for 5 days in emergency room to relieve pain and swelling. Fracture was treated conservatively. Under general anaesthesia, a below elbow plaster cast was done for 8 weeks, later converted to synthetic cast at 4th week due to patient’s discomfort with the regular cast.
Outcome and follow-up: Physiotherapy initiated at 8 weeks. She resumed normal activities assisted with a planned physiotherapy regimen at end of 8 weeks. At 3 month and 6 month follow-up the patient reported good functional outcome. At 6 months, she had a painless and complete range of motion of the left thumb (Figs 6, 7 & 8) and wrist, compared to the uninjured side. The follow-up radiographs showed normal articular relationship of the trapezium with the base of first metacarpal and scaphoid. The fracture healed with no complications (Figs 9 & 10). Though we did not formally score his function, she reported satisfactory return to all her normal activities of daily living including writing, dressing and lifting. Her grip strength was normal.
Main mechanisms for Trapezium fractures described are: a fall on the hand with the wrist extended and radially deviated (Manon) and direct commissural trauma combined with various degrees of shearing described by Monsche. Though there are various types (ridge, body, vertical, transverse, coronal and comminuted), it is the indirect force mechanism that has been attributed to fractures of the trapezium body2 The clinical presentation can be quite variable depending on the displacement of the fracture and the involvement of the carpometacarpal joint. It could be minimal, with no gross deformity and almost full range of movements of the wrist and fingers and impairment of the terminal range of opposition of the thumb. Other injuries reported in association include fracture of the proximal pole of the scaphoid, fracture of the thumb metacarpal, fracture of the distal radius, fracture of other metacarpals and fracture of other carpals, including trapezoid and capitate3. Occasionally there may also be associated ligament damage (anterior oblique ligament, dorsoradial ligament, intermetacarpal ligament, posterior oblique ligament). Thus, it is important to have a high clinical suspicion based on history and mechanism of injury2. Trapezial fractures often are unrecognized lesions; their diagnosis can only be made by radiographs with specific projections4 . Imaging consists of plain radiographs, but often undisplaced fractures can be missed on these. A true anteroposterior view (Robert’s view), done with the hand in full pronation, is a good way of visualizing the trapezium and the base of the first metacarpal clearly on plain radiographs2. Computerized Tomography or bone scintigraphy is helpful in finding out the amount of displacement and the size of the fragments and also in fractures not visualized in the plain films. The literature reports several management options. It is important to determine the stability of the joint before treatment. Especially in cases with associated dislocation, rupture of the surrounding ligaments and the dorsal joint capsule may result in instability even if the fracture itself is appropriately stabilized and these may require repair. Reconstruction of the inter-metacarpal and capsular structures, such as an inter-metacarpal abductor pollicis longus augmentation may be required5, especially in isolated dislocations. However, as it is the universally accepted orthopedic principle that fractures involving an articular surface require accurate reduction, most authors adhere to treatment involving accurate restoration of the articular surface. This is supported by two series5,6 which highlighted the need for accurate reduction of the articular surface with displacement > 2mm. Inston et al7 reported very good success rate using Herbert screw which gave dynamic compression of the fragments .One article8 reported successful conservative treatment of most undisplaced trapezium fractures in plaster cast only. Most of the literature recommends open reduction and internal fixation of vertically displaced intrarticular fractures of the trapezium. Cordrey and Ferrer-Torrells9 were the first to recommend this and they used Kirschner wire-fixation for a series of five patients. Foster and Hastings10 recommended either this or closed reduction and pinning, similar to what was done in this case. Tolat and Jones11 reported a case of a trapezium fracture with associated carpo-metacarpal dislocation in a skeletally immature 14 year old that was treated with accurate reduction and plaster and made a good recovery suggesting that accurate reduction/fixation of the trapezium may be enough to stabilize the trapezio-metacarpal joint. Recently, arthroscopic assisted fixation of this injury was reported. No studies have compared the outcome of Kirschner wire-fixation (percutaneous/open) to screw fixation (open) but Mcguigan and Culp6 looked at 11 patients (largest series) with intra-articular trapezium fractures with either articular displacement >2 mm or carpometacarpal subluxation, who had some type of surgical treatment and reported overall good outcomes however 5/11 patients in this study showed degenerative changes at the trapezio-metacarpal articulation at long-term follow-up (mean 47 months) despite excellent functional results at early review. Hence it is important to indicate this important long-term complication to all patients. Though the desired treatment for these fractures is operative, patient who refuse surgical intervention can still be successfully treated conservatively with a good molded plaster under fluoroscopy. In our case, physiotherapy played a major role to gain back the range of movements and early rehabilitation.
Carpal Fractures not always are accompanied with obvious clinical signs; hence High degree of suspicion is required for diagnosing these fractures. X-Rays supplemented with CT scan is required to understand fracture pattern orientation. Universal treatment protocol for trapezium fractures is not standardised. Undisplaced coronal non- articular fractures can be managed by conservatively. Physiotherapy plays important role in rehabilitation and recovery.
Carpal bone fractures require high degree of suspicion for diagnosis and early treatment. This is a report of rare coronal pattern of trapezial fracture that we encountered.
1. Ramoutar DN, Katevu C, Titchener AG, and Patel A.Trapezium fracture – a common technique to fix a rare injury: a case report. Cases J. 2009; 2: 8304.
2. Cannon DL.Wrist Disorders. Campbell’s operative orthopaedics.12th Edition; Vol.4, Pg.3383-3476.
3. SS Suresh.Isolated coronal split fracture of the trapezium. Indian J Orthop. 2012 Jan-Feb; 46(1): 99–101.
4. Pointu J, Schwenck JP, Destree G, Séjourné P. Fractures of the trapezium. Mechanisms. Anatomo-pathology and therapeutic indications.Arch Orthop Trauma Surg.1998; 117(3):180-2.
5. Brunelli G, Monini L, Brunelli F. Stabilisation of the trapezio-metacarpal joint. J Hand Surg Br. 1989;14:209–212.
6. McGuigan FX, Culp RW. Surgical treatment of intraarticular fractures of the trapezium. J Hand Surg [Am] 2002;27:697–703.
7. Inston N, Pimpalnekar AL, Arafa MA. Isolated fracture of the trapezium: and easily missed injury. Injury.1997;28(7):485–488
8. Jones WA, Ghorbal MS. Fractures of the trapezium. A report on three cases. J Hand Surg. 1985;10B:227–230.
9. Cordrey LJ, Ferrer-Torrells M. Management of fractures of the greater multangular. J Bone Joint Surg. 1960;42A: 1111–1118.
10. Foster RJ, Hastings H., II Treatment of Bennett, Rolando and vertical intraarticular trapezial fractures. Clin Orthop. 1987;214:121–129.
11. Tolat AR, Jones MW. Carpometacarpal dislocation of the thumb associated with fracture of the trapezium. Injury. 1990;21(6):411–412.
|How to Cite This Article: Panigrahi R, Biswal MR, Palo N, Panigrahi N. Isolated Coronal Fracture of Trapezium- A Case Report with Review of Literature. Journal of Orthopaedic Case Reports 2015 July – Sep;5(3): 29-31. Available from: http://test.jocr.co.in/2015/07/01/2250-0685-300-fulltext/|
Dear Reader, We are very excited about New Features in JOCR. Please do let us know what you think by Clicking on the Sliding “Feedback Form” button on the <<< left of the page or sending a mail to us at email@example.com